Did the Jiva Fall from the Spiritual World?

ASK BVKS | August 30, 2016 |

English with Český Translation; Brno, Czech Republic

Question:

Regading jiva's fall into this material world. Srila Prabhupada talks a lot about the fall. One devotee discovered a transcribed lecture of Srila Prabhupada on Srimad Bhagavatam 2.9.1 delivered in Tokio on April 22nd, 1972 (https://old.prabhupadavani.org/main/Bhagavatam/325.html ) in which he says that the jiva does not fall down. The devotee suggested that the jiva remains in the spiritual world but his consciousness is placed into the material world (as in a dream when one is asleep and is dreaming about visiting different countries and performing various activities). He supports his statement by citing BG in which it is said that the jiva is immovable (acala). Thus, he says it is situated in the spiritual world. So my questions are:

A.) What is meant by acala? Some say that it means that the jiva is immovable in the body. Others say that it means that the jiva never leaves the spiritual world.

B.) Does the jiva actually fall down into the material world or he remains in the spiritual world? Is he mechanically moved or it is just an illusion?

i.) I cannot understand how the jiva is simultaneously situated both in the material and spiritual worlds.
ii.) If in the material world the jiva turns away from Krsna, what does he do in the spiritual world at the same time?
iii.) What does it mean that the jiva does not fall if he really falls down?

 

Audio answer:

Play (8 m 35 s)     Download (3.9 MB)    

You can mark interesting parts of the page content and share unique link from browser address bar.

Mark




Related Lectures

Don't be Foolish, Part-5

January 20, 2015 |

English; Salem, Tamil Nadu, India

Guhya, Part-1

June 7, 2017 |

English; Udupi, Karnataka, India

Regarding Child Abuse

August 27, 2016 |

English with Český translation; Brno, Czech Republic

Kanchi Yatra Opening Speech

June 14, 2008 |

English with தமிழ் translation; Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu, India

Namakal Nama-hatta Opening

November 16, 2008 |

English; Namakkal, Tamil Nadu, India

All Glories to Balarama

August 7, 2017 |

English; Gauragrama, Telangana, India

The Path of Bhagavad-gita

January 25, 2015 |

English with தமிழ் translation; Kanchipuram, Tamil Nadu, India

Why Bhakti Is Independent of Other Forms of Yoga

August 2, 2011 |

Question: Did Prabhupada name his version of the Gita, As it is to give a sub meaning to tat tvam asi-that thou art, and aham brahmasmi. Why is it that bhakti can be attained without necessarily taking part in other forms of yoga? Narada Muni explains in the bhakti sutras that bhakti is the fruit of all yoga paths. My real question is Where is the tree or vine in relation to this metaphor?

English;

Considerations on Dealings with Followers of Various Maharastrian Saints

April 5, 2014 |

Question: In the western part of India, especially Maharashtra, there are many saints (I am not sure if this is what peoplel are supposed to call them) like Swami Samartha, Sant Dnyāneshwar, and Giriraj Maharaja whose followers are mostly simple and poor villagers. HG Caitanya Charan Prabhu mentioned in www.thespiritualscientist.com that devotees are supposed to respect them and glorify them for whatever bhakti they are doing, although they are using chanting or glorification of the Lord as a tool to gain followers and ultimately make them Mayavadis.… Expand>

Question:

I have been listening to your holiness' lectures for about 5 months day and night and I like the philosophical clarity of thought by which your holiness presents Krishna Consciousness, and of course the quality of the recording is nice.

I have also heard all of your Holiness' Q&A audio lectures available on the internet before asking this question.

In the western part of India, especially Maharashtra, there are many saints (I am not sure if this is what peoplel are supposed to call them) like Swami Samartha, Sant Dnyāneshwar, and Giriraj Maharaja whose followers are mostly simple and poor villagers. HG Caitanya Charan Prabhu mentioned in www.thespiritualscientist.com that devotees are supposed to respect them and glorify them for whatever bhakti they are doing, although they are using chanting or glorification of the Lord as a tool to gain followers and ultimately make them Mayavadis.

But the problem in practical application is that if we respect them then they will think that we are approving of their activities. For example most of their followers are vegetarian but they feel  that tea does not break their fast on Ekadashi, so they consume tea on their fasting days also.

Are these Maharaja's with their sampradaya's bona fide? If yes then which Sampradaya do they belong to?

In most rural parts of Maharashtra we don't have ISKCON centers, But we do have maths of the above mentioned personalities, so what should be our attitude towards the followers of the above mentioned personalities?

And what should be our approach to bring them to Krishna Consciousness as we don't have any ISKCON centers here? What are the do’s and don't we should follow to bring them to the service of Srila Prabhupada, or if not that then at least a bona fide Guru Parampara?

Can we or do we have a website or any such means where it is clearly stated that XYZ math or Sampradaya is bona fide or not bona fide, so at least we don't offend the ones who are outside of ISKCON and belong to a bona fide sampradaya and do not promote (by respecting them) the bogus so called spiritualist?

I do not intend to hurt any devotee, my only motive is to seek the truth or clarity of thought for healthy spiritual progress. Please forgive me for any offenses.

^ Show less

English; Rishikesh, Uttarakhand, India

Prahlada's Apparent Prayers for Material Benediction

July 3, 2015 |

Question: I could understand from Srimad Bhagavatam that Sri Prahalada Maharaja is fearless, he is a pure devotee of the Lord and does not ask for any material benefits from the Lord. But in the Nrsimha Kavaca mantra it states that; “Oh Lord please protect me from west, east, north etc. and there is also the phalastruti (result of reciting the kavaca) which states that one attains material benedictions like putrvan (good son), dhanavan (wealth), long life etc.… Expand>

Question:

I could understand from Srimad Bhagavatam that Sri Prahlada Maharaja is fearless, he is a pure devotee of the Lord and does not ask for any material benefits from the Lord. But in the Nrsimha Kavaca mantra it states that; “Oh Lord please protect me from west, east, north etc. and there is also the phalastruti (result of reciting the kavaca) which states that one attains material benedictions like putrvan (good son), dhanavan (wealth), long life etc.

Maharaja, kindly explain how to understand these two different moods of Prahlada Maharaja.

^ Show less

English; Colombo, Sri Lanka

Diplomacy and Duplicity

March 4, 2014 |

English; Secunderabad, Andhra Pradesh, India

  • Śrī Caitanya-caritāmṛta 2.12.44

  • 45 m 3 s  |  20.7 MB

  • Download
  • Play

Envy is very bad

December 4, 2013 |

English; Nanda Gokulam, Andhra Pradesh, India

The Attractiveness of Srila Prabhupada, Part-4

August 23, 2014 |

English; Govindadvipa, Ireland

Dharmakrt - Accusations Against Krsna, Part-1

August 20, 2016 |

English; Inish Rath, Ireland

What is Krsna Consciousness?, Part-1

October 25, 2016 |

English; Gauragrama, Telangana, India

We Are Our Own Worst Enemy

May 18, 2005 |

English with தமிழ் translation; Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India

Reflection and Original

March 4, 2011 |

Question: I heard from some devotee that everything present here in this world is the perverted form or the reflection of the original things present in the spiritual world. So please explain me the positive form of sex and sexual desires.

English;

Dharmakrt - Accusations Against Krsna, Part-3

August 21, 2016 |

English; Inish Rath, Ireland

Nirvanam, Bheshajam, Bhishak

August 13, 2017 |

English; Gauragrama, Telangana, India

  • Viṣṇu-sahasranāma 584-586

  • 50 m 36 s  |  23.2 MB

  • Download
  • Play

Full Consciousness

September 27, 2015 |

English; Dallas, Texas, USA