How Did Sukadeva Become an Impersonalist Even He Knew That Krishna is Supreme?

ASK BVKS | August 2, 2012 |

English;

Question:

How was it possible that Sukadeva Goswami became an impersonalist (Brahmavadi) but then became attracted to Krishna’s personalistic activities?

I ask this because I have heard from senior devotees that Suka is parrot of Radharani and that in his form as a parrot, he heard Bhagavatam from Lord Siva while he was explaining it to Mother Parvathi.

Also Sukadeva Goswami remained in the womb of his mother (Bitika) for around 16 years as he refused to come out. But after Krishna assured him that he will not be attracted by His Maya energy, then he came out. This means that Suka knows Krishna is supreme. Then how did he become an impersonalist.

Audio answer:

Play (4 m 20 s)     Download (4 MB)    

You can mark interesting parts of the page content and share unique link from browser address bar.

Mark




Related Lectures

A Society Made of Brahmanas

October 31, 2011 |

Question: I am currently listening to your lecture "Some Concerns About ISKCON." I also heard a lecture recently from my spritual master HH Tamal Krishna Goswami. He said, "originally, Srila Prabhupada wanted ISKCON to consist solely of brahmacaris and sannyasis, but then Jadurani came, what was Srila Prabhupada to do? He couldn't reject her."… Expand>

Question:

I am currently listening to your lecture "Some Concerns About ISKCON." I also heard a lecture recently from my spritual master HH Tamal Krishna Goswami. He said, "originally, Srila Prabhupada wanted ISKCON to consist solely of brahmacaris and sannyasis, but then Jadurani came, what was Srila Prabhupada to do? He couldn't reject her."

It seems that since we do not discriminate who joins ISKCON in terms of their varna or ashram, ISKCON will continue to face these sorts of issues (i.e. Ksatriya Initiative).

My question: Although I understand that we are ultimately only concerned with becoming Vaishnavas, but do you forsee that ISKCON as a society will gradually evolve into strictly a brahminical body as Srila Prabhupada wanted or will the brahminical class be forced to create a seperate body to offer guidance to society? Thank you for maintaining the standard. 

^ Show less

English;

Four Great Vaisnavas

February 13, 2016 |

English with తెలుగు translation; Bhimavaram, Andhra Pradesh, India

Lokadhyaksa, Suradhyaksa, Dharmadhyaksa

September 3, 2012 |

English; Denver, Colorado, USA

Should I attend a Wedding?

May 1, 2016 |

Question: My brother is having his wedding in the summer time on the east coast. I truly don’t want anything to do with weddings and especially those of materialists. I am close with my brother as him and his fiancé are both sweet people. (vegetarians, "half-devotees"). He comes to the temple for festivals and lets me use his facilities as I like (he lives in one of best book distribution places) Boulder, CO. Anyway, I’m saying all this because I truly just don’t know what to do. They really want me to go but I know it will be like hell and so painful to be around all the materialists eating, drinking, and being merry.… Expand>

Question:

My brother is having his wedding in the summer time on the east coast. I truly don’t want anything to do with weddings and especially those of materialists. I am close with my brother as him and his fiancé are both sweet people. (vegetarians, "half-devotees"). He comes to the temple for festivals and lets me use his facilities as I like (he lives in one of best book distribution places) Boulder, CO. Anyway, I’m saying all this because I truly just don’t know what to do. They really want me to go but I know it will be like hell and so painful to be around all the materialists eating, drinking, and being merry.

ANSWER by HH Bhakti Vikasa Swami: 

"Well, that’s good enough reason to go because, hopefully, in the normal course of events people only get married once in their life. So, it’s a big thing.

Maybe in America it’s 1.5 times or something like that, by average. Of course, you can’t get married 1.5 times, but on average... Or maybe it’s 2.5. I don’t know. Or maybe it’s just 1 because so many people get divorced and so many people don’t get married at all. It doesn’t mean they’ve all became monks. They are vyabhicari (unchaste). They are having sexual liaisons without marrying. So, that’s a good reason to go.

Babhru Prabhu is concerned about: I have to go...and all those materialistic people...

Well, it could also be a good preaching opportunity and as much as you are there, and you are a devotee, they’ll ask you few questions: Why do you like this? And you can explain to them. You could take books, and distribute them also. So, anyway, you have to decide.

I’m not gonna decide for you. It’s the other side of the country. America is a big country. I think more than twice as big as India. So, you can imagine. But, anyway, you can fly around. You have to have money. So, anyway, you decide what to do.

I wouldn’t go because I’m a sannyasi. But you are not. So, you can take an opportunity to please your brother, help him, give him some encouragement in devotional service. You can give him a set of Srila Prabhupada’s books. It’s a great wedding gift.

What do people give? I think they give mixies. I think when people get married they get 20 mixies so they have to sell them back. Mixie-no one outside of India knows what it is. It’s an Indian-English word. What’s the English word? Food blender or something like that.

So, give a set of Bhagavatam. It’s a great gift. That’s my advice, as you’ve asked for it, but it’s up to you.

Hare Krishna!"

^ Show less

English; Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India

Martyrs of the D-day

April 12, 2014 |

Question: I have a doubt in my mind, and you could most likely solve it. Sannyasa is the highest ashram and generally the sannyasis are respected as being; as good as God by other sections. I hear stories about Prabhupada offering sannyasa to many of his devotees, and many of them could not maintain it. During the early stages of the Krishna Conscious movement, was Prabhupada very careful in choosing candidates for Sannyasa?… Expand>

Question:

I have a doubt in my mind, and you could most likely solve it.

Sannyasa is the highest ashram and generally the sannyasis are respected as being; as good as God by other sections. I hear stories about Prabhupada offering sannyasa to many of his devotees, and many of them could not maintain it.

During the early stages of the Krishna Conscious movement, was Prabhupada very careful in choosing candidates for Sannyasa? I hear stories that sometimes many of the devotees were given Sannyasa on a single day and were asked to go out and preach (please correct me if I am wrong).

Is the spiritual master supposed to understand the possible frailties of his disciples very carefully and give instructions only according to the disciple’s capacity? I hear this argument that the strength to carry on the instruction is imparted with the instruction itself.

Is it possible that the spiritual master may give an instruction, but if he is not very helpful to the disciple then the disciple has to take a simpler instruction for himself after the failure?

How does giving instructions work in the current context? We have many madhyama bhaktas acting as leaders, so are we supposed to check with others when there are strict instructions (other than chanting and regulative principles) and strong ideas presented that are directly not in Prabhupada's books - like preaching, program building etc.?

^ Show less

English; Rishikesh, Uttarakhand, India

Introductory Lecture

February 23, 2008 |

English; Batticaloa, Sri Lanka

Aspiring for the Inconceivable

September 30, 2013 |

English; Coventry, England

Natural Epistemology – Part 1

February 18, 2011 |

English; Baroda, Gujarat, India

Don't be Foolish, Part-6

January 28, 2015 |

English; Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India

Aspiring to be a Gopi

August 13, 2014 |

English; Govindadvipa, Ireland

  • Śrīmad-Bhāgavatam 10.15.18-20

  • 51 m 27 s  |  23.6 MB

  • Download
  • Play

Guru Does Not Cheat

September 17, 2012 |

English; New Orleans, Louisiana, USA

  • Śrī Caitanya-caritāmṛta 3.4.102-103

  • 50 m 2 s  |  22.9 MB

  • Download
  • Play

Why Men and Women should Sit Separately

January 16, 2015 |

English; Salem, Tamil Nadu, India

Perceiving, Preserving and Distributing the Message of Srimad Bhagavatam

February 21, 2016 |

English; Hyderabad, Telangana, India

Celebrating Srila Prabhupada's US Arrival

October 2, 2015 |

English;

Blissful Renunciation

June 11, 2011 |

English; San Diego, California, USA

Fifty Years of ISKCON

July 28, 2016 |

English with Русский translation; Nizhny Novgorod, Russia

Talk To School Children

February 24, 2008 |

English with தமிழ் translation; Thirukkovil, Tamil Nadu, India

Meaning of Worshiping Lotus Feet of a Pure Devotee

April 30, 2011 |

Question: 1) What does it actually mean by worshiping lotus feet of a pure devotee or Lord HImself. 2) Whom should we worship: our acharyas lotus feet (Rupa Goswami and Jiva Goswami Prabhupada) or Radha Krishna's lotus feet (which are rarely attained).

English;

Preaching via Facebook

September 27, 2011 |

Question: The question is not available now.

English;

The Attractiveness of Srila Prabhupada, Part-5

August 24, 2014 |

English; Govindadvipa, Ireland